Writing a Book Review

  I. Form of the Review

    A. Introduction

        1. Who is the author?

        2. What is the reason for writing the book?

        3. What makes the author qualified to write on the subject?

        4. In general, what is contained in the book?  Give a brief overall summary of the information in the book

    B. Body of the Review

        1. Give criticisms, both favorable and unfavorable.

        2. Point out strengths and weaknesses.

        3. Comment on style and presentation.

        4. Evaluate the author's emphases and/or hang-ups.

        5. Comment on the sources used by the author and how they affect his conclusions.

        6. Evaluate additional aspects of the book, e.g. illustrations, maps, charts, bibliographies, etc.

    C. Conclusion

        1. Did the author accomplish what he set out to do?

        2. Does the book have any use?

        3. Who will benefit from reading it?

        4. What is your personal opinion or observations?

 II. General Rules for Writing

        1. Avoid clichés - use your own words and ideas.

        2. Use as few quotes as possible.

        3. If you do not like the book, say so - but support your opinion with information.

        4. Do not announce what you intend to do, i.e. "Now I am going to discuss..."

        5. Organize your paper so that your statements follow a logical sequence.

        6. Strive for a concise, coherent, and precise style.  Do not drown your ideas in a flood of words!

III. All reviews must be proofed, with no spelling or typing errors.  Grammar should also be perfect.